Balvenie 12yo Doublewood is in Blue Writing and The Signature is in Red Writing
Sig Nose: Dry marzipan, and some dry sherry notes. Quite malty in fact. With time whisky becomes more sherried on the nose.
DW Nose: Still dry and with almonds and the sherry note is more pronounced although there is more of a background creaminess! Plums! And a hint of dark chocolate.
Sig Taste: Initially starts out like it is going to be thick - if only not 40% abv! Again drying and a little woody, touch of marzipan and faint cherries. Reasonably nice just a little thin.
DW Taste: Fuller in the taste - still a little dry and with a touch of hessian sack but strangely in a good way. Also decent amounts of creaminess, reminiscent of ice cream toffee sauce.
Sig Finish: Very short - I thought there was none then a warming hit me in the middle of the throat and subtle oak.
DW Finish: Dry and slightly sherry clawing but fairly short bar the front of the mouth that is puckered dry.
Comment: Both good staple everyday drams but nothing spectacular. If I had to plump for one I would be hard pushed and I would say doublewood edges it on the finish.
Scores: 86 doublewood and 85 signature